Beyond GDP: Why Development Must Be Measured Through Human Dignity, Social Justice and Equality
Dr. Lenin Raghuvanshi of PVCHR calls for grassroots realities, Dalit rights and human dignity to shape the United Nations' Beyond GDP framework
Varanasi, India | November 2026
Can a country be considered developed when its economy is growing but its poorest citizens continue to experience hunger, caste discrimination, violence, exploitation and exclusion from justice?
This fundamental question lies at the heart of the global discussion on moving Beyond Gross Domestic Product (GDP). The debate is not simply about developing new economic indicators. It is about redefining progress through human dignity, equality, social justice, well-being and the lived experiences of people.
Dr. Lenin Raghuvanshi, Co-Founder of the People's Vigilance Committee on Human Rights (PVCHR) and associated with Jan Mitra Nyas, has contributed grassroots perspectives from India to the ongoing United Nations intergovernmental process on Beyond GDP.
The process is being facilitated during the 81st session of the United Nations General Assembly under the leadership of Spain and Malaysia.
Moving Beyond Economic Growth
GDP measures the monetary value of goods and services produced within an economy. Although it remains an important economic indicator, it cannot independently capture the quality of people's lives, the distribution of wealth, social inequalities, environmental sustainability or the protection of fundamental human rights.
For communities experiencing poverty and structural discrimination, economic growth does not automatically translate into dignity, security or equal opportunities.
Drawing on nearly three decades of grassroots human rights work in India, Lenin Raghuvanshi emphasised that development must be assessed through the actual conditions of the most marginalised communities.
In his communication to the Secretariat, he welcomed the Beyond GDP initiative and highlighted the importance of incorporating human rights, multidimensional poverty, structural inequalities, decent work, food security, nutrition and meaningful participation by civil society and local communities.
Six Priorities from Grassroots India
In his contribution, Lenin Raghuvanshi highlighted six interconnected priorities for consideration within the Beyond GDP framework.
1. Social and Caste Justice
Development indicators must recognise caste-based discrimination, untouchability, social exclusion and structural inequalities, particularly affecting Dalits, Adivasis and other historically marginalised communities.
Economic growth cannot be considered inclusive when entire communities continue to experience discrimination and unequal access to opportunities.
2. Human Dignity and Human Rights
Freedom from torture, custodial violence, bonded labour, trafficking and exploitation must be recognised as essential dimensions of human progress.
A society cannot claim meaningful development while people remain vulnerable to violence and violations of their fundamental rights.
3. Nutrition, Health and Food Security
Economic progress must be assessed alongside access to adequate nutrition, healthcare, safe drinking water and food security, especially for children and vulnerable families.
4. Decent Work and Livelihood Security
The framework should capture informal employment, wage insecurity, bonded labour, child labour and the working conditions of daily-wage workers.
The dignity of work must become a central measure of development.
5. Gender Equality and Children's Well-being
Women's agency, unpaid care work, access to education, child protection and intergenerational poverty deserve meaningful recognition in development measurement.
6. Community Participation and Accountability
People experiencing poverty and exclusion must participate in defining development priorities. Civil society organisations and grassroots communities should be treated as partners in shaping the framework, rather than merely as consultees.
The United Nations Process: An Opportunity for Civil Society
On 10 November 2026, the Permanent Missions of Malaysia and Spain to the United Nations circulated a communication outlining their approach to facilitating the intergovernmental process.
The communication reaffirmed their commitment to an inclusive and transparent process, providing meaningful opportunities for Member States to engage and contribute.
The accompanying indicative roadmap, as of November 2026, identifies several important milestones:
- 18 November 2026: First thematic deep-dive discussion.
- 1 December 2026: Second thematic deep-dive discussion.
- 14 December 2026: First informal consultation on the Elements Paper and the way forward.
- Up to 14 December 2026: Dedicated hybrid engagement with non-Member State stakeholders.
- 23 December 2026: Coordinators issue the zero draft resolution.
- January 2027: Further consultations and dedicated stakeholder engagement.
- February–March 2027: Successive revisions and consultations on the draft resolution.
- Late March/early April 2027: Expected adoption of the resolution by the General Assembly.
The roadmap provides an important opportunity for civil society organisations to contribute evidence, experiences and perspectives as the framework develops.
Acknowledgement from the Secretariat
Following Lenin Raghuvanshi's communication, the Secretariat responded with appreciation for his support during the intergovernmental process on Beyond GDP.
"We are grateful for the insights you shared. Your emphasis on dignity, social justice and the lived realities of the most marginalized communities is extremely relevant."
The Secretariat also welcomed his interest in contributing grassroots evidence and community experiences, and indicated that it would keep him informed about upcoming opportunities for civil society engagement.
This acknowledgement is an encouraging recognition of the importance of connecting international policy discussions with the experiences of communities at the grassroots level.
Why PVCHR Believes Grassroots Evidence Matters
The People's Vigilance Committee on Human Rights (PVCHR), working through Jan Mitra Nyas, has spent nearly three decades documenting human rights violations and supporting marginalised communities in India.
Its work includes torture prevention, custodial violence documentation, Testimonial Therapy, psychosocial rehabilitation, legal assistance, Dalit rights, Musahar community development, women's empowerment and children's rights.
PVCHR's Work During 2025
160 torture-related cases documented.
151 survivors received psychosocial and legal support.
₹1.08 crore approximately in compensation secured for survivors.
These experiences demonstrate why development indicators must go beyond national averages. They must capture whether people are safe, whether they can access justice, whether children receive adequate nutrition, whether women exercise agency and whether historically excluded communities enjoy equal dignity and opportunity.
A country's progress cannot be understood without listening to those who experience inequality most directly.
Development Must Be Measured Through Human Lives
The Beyond GDP initiative presents an important opportunity to reconsider the meaning of development in the twenty-first century.
For PVCHR, a genuinely transformative framework must answer one fundamental question:
If the economy is growing, are the lives of the poorest, most excluded and most vulnerable people actually improving?
This question must remain central to global development policy.
Ultimately, development should not be measured merely by the wealth a country produces, but also by how it eliminates suffering, reduces inequality, protects human dignity and expands the capabilities and freedoms of every human being.
The challenge before the international community is to ensure that the Beyond GDP framework does not simply replace one statistical measure with another, but creates a more humane understanding of progress.
The true measure of development is not only how much wealth a nation creates, but how much dignity, equality, justice and freedom its people enjoy.
About PVCHR
The People's Vigilance Committee on Human Rights (PVCHR) began its human rights work in 1996. Jan Mitra Nyas, established in 1999, is its legal holder. The organisations work to advance human rights, social justice, democratic accountability and the dignity of marginalised communities.
PVCHR: https://pvchr.blogspot.com/
Jan Mitra Nyas: https://janmitranyas.in/
Organisational Reports: https://janmitranyas.in/report.html
_page-0001.jpg)
_page-0002.jpg)








.jpeg)

.jpeg)


.jpeg)

.jpeg)
.jpeg)




